Back to writing

[languagelearning]

Korean progress report

    Table of contents
  1. Introduction
  2. Goals
  3. Journey so far
  4. What I'm doing right now
  5. Change of pace
  6. Anki
  7. Language exchange groups
  8. So this is how they get me
  9. Navel gazing
  10. Artifacting
  11. Conclusion

Introduction (§)

This is a bit of a journal entry, a bit of a progress report, a bit of a snapshot of my Korean learning progress. I've never given a progress report on my Korean study despite making passing mention of it as far back as 2020 in other articles. There are reasons for this, some of which may become clear in time. But, for other reasons, I have decided it's time I finally do this kind of update.

I would like to make it very clear that the things I say here are thoughts and feelings, not necessarily facts or recommendations unless explicitly stated.

You know that I like for these articles to get long, and I like to think they are complete before publishing. But of course this is something that will never be complete. And although I can tell myself I should wait until the next milestone before this is worth sharing, I can also say that the milestones I've passed so far are worth sharing. And, since it takes some minimum amount of time for me to think and write, this snapshot is really more of a temporal smear anyway. It's nice to have a deadline.

I started studying Korean on October 5, 2018. Day one, hour zero. That day is eight years ago, but I do not say, and I can not say, that I've been studying for eight years, because I haven't. Although eight years have passed, I have fallen off course more than once, more than twice.

In a way, it would be nicer for my ego to not know exactly how much I've studied and how much I haven't. What I mean by that is my skill level is still not very high. This is the crux of the matter. So if I were to say I've been studying for eight years and can not confidently hold an adult conversation, it would be quite a tragedy and a failure, and would reflect very poorly on my abilities and intellect. On the other hand, if I were to say that I've done only one year of "actual study" and seven years of being off course, that would... well, it would still reflect poorly on my discipline, time management, and priorities, but it wouldn't mean I'm quite as stupid. So you see what I mean, it is perhaps better for the ego to not really know for sure.

But of course, we do know for sure, because Anki reveals the truth. I wasn't using Anki from day one, but once I started, it looks like I did two years of consistent, but admittedly not very intensive[1] study. By 2021 the heatmap becomes pale as I was clearly having some days of trying a little harder, and some days of doing the bare minimum to not technically break the streak. This continued through 2022 with light and patchy study and broken streaks. All of 2023, 2024, 2025 represent essentially no study. In May of 2026 I became reinvigorated, which leads us to today.

[1] The color scale on the heatmap is relative to each year. The highest day in 2020 barely crests 600 reviews which is now my daily average.

Goals (§)

Why did I start learning Korean at all? I suppose the simplest answer is... 한국여자 예쁘니까. If you're not happy with that answer, you can spare me the comments. I have more thoughts on this than you'd ever want to hear. In fact, I have more thoughts on this than I'd ever want to hear, but they are in my head and I am stuck with them.

In college, and especially during my last year of college, I felt like I was surrounded by people who knew two, three, or even four languages. It made me feel inadequate and pushed me to get back into language. "Back into" meaning that I had taken four years of high school French and one year of college French and couldn't hold an actual conversation, though I did read most of L'Etranger. This kind of experience is pretty common, and has either to do with high school language classes letting everyone off too easily, or the student not having enough intrinsic motivation — understandably since language classes are a school requirement. But anyway, I felt like French wasn't sparking my curiousity at this point in time.

For a period of several years I was very hardcore into watching movies. I watched lots of movies, both domestic and foreign including French, Japanese, Chinese, German, Russian, Swedish, Spanish, Mexican, Thai, Polish, and Minnesotan. There was just something about Korean that I liked the most. Some of my favorites are 친절한 금자씨, 봄, 여름, 가을, 겨울 그리고 봄, and 사마리아. In my article on Ghost Dog I already explored some of the American/Western fascination with East Asia, and I am in this aura as well. I've always liked ninjas. I mean who doesn't like ninjas. So besides French, it was pretty obvious that if I choose to learn another language it would be an Asian language, and amongst the big three CJK, I like Korean the best. Partly this is because every other white person is already obsessed with Japan and I like to avoid doing the most popular thing. Partly this is because I like the sound of Korean more than the sound of Chinese, though Japanese is pretty as well. Partly this is because the Korean alphabet is interesting from both a technical and historical perspective, and makes learning to read so, so, so much easier than the other two.

Then, why have I suddenly become reinvigorated? Well, I recently passed my 30th birthday and... you know how it is when people pass a decade. I've had to think about my priorities and goals in life. For all these years I've been dissatisfied with my Korean study. I have felt like a failure and, despite having an interest in the language, this interest has carried a sense of shame and embarassment because, if I were to want to tell someone anything about it, and if they were to ask me "oh, you know Korean?" my answer would truthfully be "uh, not really". So it has been a kind of secret that I carry and don't tell anyone about because all it does is reveal my failure. So, it's time for me to really do this, and take it more seriously, and not be a failure. I am the kind of person that goes through lots of hobby phases and dabbles in all kinds of things and very explicitly does not intend to become an expert in all of them. But the fact that I'm still interested in Korean after all this time seems to suggest it's not just one of those phases.

To be more precise, my wave of renewed motivation started after Matt vs Japan uploaded a new video, which led me to discover that he actually has a second channel now, and also to rewatch a lot of his older videos. The content of the video that re-motivated me wasn't particularly out of the ordinary for Matt. It was just good timing.

In some circles, Matt has earned a negative reputation, but I'm not part of all that and that's not my relationship to the material he's made. I've never paid for anyone's courses or resources of any kind, I just watch the videos he's made for free and, as far as I'm concerned, his information is both good and motivational. The ideas and philosophies behind input-centric study resonate with me. You may like to read my previous article Are children better at learning languages? for more thoughts on that.

Suffice to say, I appreciate the things Matt has shared during his language learning journey of over fifteen years, and this is part of the reason I feel I should express my own thoughts here.

To say a little more about these goals and priorities brings us back to 한국여자 예쁘다. By the time you get to the age of 30, everyone around you is trying to get out of the dating phase. Everyone is "dating with intention" and "looking for my future husband" and "done wasting time". So I don't want to waste anybody's time who feels like their clock is ticking and, if I meet someone who isn't Korean, no matter how nice and sweet and pretty she may be, what would I do with all this Korean? There are plenty of pretty girls out there that I wouldn't mind spending time with, but at the moment I cannot see myself becoming committed with someone not Korean. Not until I have some catastrophic crash-and-burn disaster relationship that changes my mind, perhaps. I won't bore you with the rest of my thoughts on this, now. So the other option is to get back in there and actually learn it this time.

Journey so far (§)

When someone asks me how I learned Korean, my answer is... well my answer is 아직 안 배웠는데?. But let me try to give you an idea of the study resources I've used on my journey so far. I have not taken any classes or worked through any textbooks.

On my very first day of study in 2018, I downloaded Duolingo. I used it for a few weeks and decided it was not very good, and the consensus online at the time was that their material for Korean was not good, so I deleted it.

I next used Lingodeer for a period of a few weeks or a few months, and it was probably better than Duolingo but truthfully I don't remember very much about it.

For the first few months of my study, I was reading through the lessons on howtostudykorean.com. This is where I got my grasp on the alphabet, pronunciation, and basic grammar points. Although I have not done a critical re-read of his lessons since then, my memories of HTSK are positive and I would recommend them, especially since they're all free. Being the type of person that I am, I've even downloaded all the webpages and turned them into an epub ebook file.

In December 2018 I downloaded HelloTalk, which is an app that connects you with someone for language exchange. This is not an endorsement since I haven't used it since then and don't know what their reputation is in 2026. On HelloTalk, I met someone that I liked and, by April 2019, we were in a long-distance romantic relationship. Of course, there was the goal of meeting up, but between the impacts of Covid, some changes in her educational and career goals, and my cowardice to take a leap, this did not happen, and we eventually broke up in 2022.

The truth is, she and I never had any significant conversations in Korean. Her English skill was very good, my Korean skill was not very good, and I did not have the courage to be willing to fail in the way you need to to speak a language. So our conversations were always in English. But we did read catlab articles and fairy tales together. Although I did not do very much language study with her, I learned lots of cultural touchpoints and the kinds of things you don't get from a textbook. You know, like this.

My primary listening resource has been Talk To Me In Korean's Iyagi series, which ran most of its course from 2010 to 2012. These are 5-10 minute conversations between two members of the TTMIK team. They used to be all available for free on Soundcloud, and I downloaded them along with the transcripts. The episodes are no longer available for free. I have listened to each of these 145 episodes so so so so so many times by now. Some of them are still difficult for me, although some of them I can follow pretty well. The reason the harder ones are still hard is because I just haven't taken the time to thoroughly scour the transcripts for whatever it is that I'm missing. In a way, I do feel that it has been an imperfect use of my time to listen to material so high above my skill level for most of this period, and I would have been better served by some more comprehensible input. But, I've always liked the fact that in Iyagi they strike a good balance of speaking clearly and properly (because they know their audience is learners), without speaking baby-talk or dumbing it down. It is difficult to find a resource that is at the right skill level and also available in large quantities to download, though part of that difficulty is just the friction of stepping out of my comfort zone to go search for something new.

My primary reading resource has been fairy tales (전래동화). I said I've never paid for any resources but, well, I guess I've found other ways of getting them. I have a large book of 전래동화 and have read through quite a few. It's neat to learn some of the stories that most Korean people would probably know from their own childhood. Though, there are some stories where nobody did anything wrong and everyone dies and I wonder what was the point.

When you put this all together, my study regimen so far has been fairy tales, a single defunct podcast, and branching through the dictionary to find more words? It's no surprise I'm not an expert yet. But somehow it seems like my results are coming along ok, considering.

I have had some difficulty finding youtube channels that are of an appropriate difficulty level and are enjoyable to watch. One channel I've found recently is 태웅쌤 - Comprehensible Input Korean. He plays video games and describes / narrates what he's doing using easy sentences, but again not baby talk. I think video games are good idea as a source of comprehensible input since he can point to things on screen and describe what's happening without having to give any English translations.

What I'm doing right now (§)

At the moment, I'm in the mood to absolutely cram vocabulary. I have much more to say specifically about Anki in a few minutes, but basically, I am trying to do 100 new words per day and am averaging 600-1000 reviews per day, which takes me between 60-90 minutes. On the Anki forums, people recommend 20 new words per day as a starting point and say that, depending on your parameters, you can expect to do 7x to 10x your New quantity per day in reviews. Some of that information comes from the days before FSRS but it's a general guideline. Looking at my historical Anki heatmap, it seems I was probably living by those guidelines since I seldom did over 200 reviews back in the day.

During my recent restart, though, I realized... my entire Anki collection only has about 7,000 cards (which is now over 8,000 as I've been adding more), and I thought if I can do 100 new per day, I'll get through the whole deck in just 70 days. That's over 1% of the collection in new per day! That doesn't mean I'll have all 7,000 cards perfectly memorized, and certainly not perfectly acquired, of course, but at least they'll be in rotation, they'll have seeds planted in my brain, they'll be hooks into the listening that I do and, really, 70 days is not a long time at all. In the grand scheme of things, across all the time that I've spent studying and all the time that I've not spent studying, 70 days is truly nothing.

To tell the truth, I do simply enjoy the party-trick aspect of having a high vocabulary, even if I can hardly use these words in a sentence. I know that memorizing low-frequency words is not the most important thing I could be doing with my time. But again, wasting a little bit of time over 70 days is a paltry sin compared to the past three years during which I've done absolutely no study at all.

Having a high vocabulary really does make listening so much easier, because your brain has a larger set of candidate words to work with, whereas if you have a small vocabulary it is hard to know what might have been a word and what might have been two words and what might have been a grammar form. Furthermore, it is a misconception to think that low-corpus-frequency words are less important to learn. They're often the words that define the entire point of the conversation. So to think that within the next 70 days I can at least pat myself on the back for having 7,000 words under my belt seems like a very worthwhile trade.

And 60-90 minutes is really not that hard to accomplish. I have found that I am really bad at studying while I'm at home, though. At home, I get distracted too easily and can hardly get myself to do more than 50 reviews before closing Anki for reasons that I don't fully understand. I have to get out of the house, so I go sit in the nearby plaza and do my reviews out there. On some days, I've been there for nearly three hours doing reviews, digging through the dictionary, looking up images of vocabulary, making new cards, and updating my existing cards.

I will go ahead and clarify that when I say "party trick", I mean of course that is it relative to the rest of my abilities. On an absolute scale, I am still learning basic words — card #7945 in my collection is 기저귀. Diaper. It is only a party trick in the sense that after someone rightfully judges my ability to be fairly low, they'll be impressed that I know words like 백수, 격주, 맨투맨, 줄임말. Those are from experience.

In 2024, I did a massive reset on my Anki cards to set them all back to "new" status, because I had not kept up on my reviews. I decided it was better to reset them all and let the easy ones graduate again rather than wreak havoc on the intervals. Of course I didn't actually start studying again in 2024, but anyway. So although I am doing 100 "new" cards per day, a lot of these are actually coming back to me very quickly, and it's not the same as actually encountering 100 new words from scratch, and my experience of doing Anki this way is not the same as it would be for someone who's actually starting right now.

There are of course some days that I don't finish all my scheduled reviews, which mainly are the days that I go to language exchange. On those days I am up in the morning at 5:30, working until 4:00, driving until 5:00, have 2 hours until the meeting, and am not back home until 10:00-11:00. So those two hours from 5:00 to 7:00 are my time to eat dinner and do some Anki, but also I take this opportunity to explore some of the local points of interest because I don't normally spend much time over there. I'd rather visit some places I've never been before than sit in my car doing Anki before the meeting starts. So usually I have a backlog to catch up on Fridays.

* * *

I wrote the above a few weeks ago and, unsurprisingly, my hubris has caught up with me. I am intentionally trying to keep my life as busy as possible, getting out and meeting people and all that. Even 60 minutes of study is not always attainable. Also, the past few weeks of August have been way too hot outside, making it impossible to sit in my usual plaza spot for study, and I truly am unable to bring myself to study at home.

So, I have now gone several weeks without breaking through the due cards into the new. This slows down my "70 days" timeline into at least 90-100 days minimum, and that's only if I can get back on track and stay there. But that's ok, this is still quick in the grand scheme, and some of the things I've been doing with my time are more important than Anki.

* * *

As I near the publication date of this article, I'm at the point where my remaining count of New cards is lower than my typical Saturday/Sunday review count. Should I...?

Here's my Anki stats from this time period. I wrote a quick and dirty, non-optimized script to pull the point-in-time history: ankipit.py. I'm not sure my method was 100% correct but it's pretty close.

date total cards new learning relearning young mature studied today mature retention new studied
2026-05-14 (목) 6743 6593 29 0 121 0 0 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-05-15 (금) 6743 6499 21 0 223 0 452 0/0 (n/a) 94
2026-05-16 (토) 6744 6500 21 0 223 0 4 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-05-17 (일) 6744 6482 19 0 243 0 82 0/0 (n/a) 18
2026-05-18 (월) 6750 6180 109 2 456 3 1026 0/0 (n/a) 308
2026-05-19 (화) 6750 6180 107 2 458 3 713 0/0 (n/a) 303
2026-05-20 (수) 6752 6182 107 2 458 3 641 0/0 (n/a) 176
2026-05-21 (목) 6756 6186 107 2 458 3 1040 0/0 (n/a) 232
2026-05-22 (금) 6756 6186 107 2 458 3 230 0/0 (n/a) 102
2026-05-23 (토) 6756 6186 107 2 458 3 10 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-05-24 (일) 6757 6187 107 2 458 3 582 0/0 (n/a) 154
2026-05-25 (월) 6757 6187 107 2 458 3 35 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-05-26 (화) 6761 6191 107 2 458 3 182 0/0 (n/a) 15
2026-05-27 (수) 6761 6191 107 2 458 3 112 0/0 (n/a) 11
2026-05-28 (목) 6766 6196 107 2 458 3 348 0/0 (n/a) 100
2026-05-29 (금) 6768 6198 107 2 458 3 42 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-05-30 (토) 6772 6202 107 2 458 3 625 0/0 (n/a) 174
2026-05-31 (일) 6783 6213 107 2 458 3 440 0/0 (n/a) 64
2026-06-01 (월) 6788 6218 107 2 458 3 838 0/0 (n/a) 213
2026-06-02 (화) 6789 6219 107 2 458 3 202 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-06-03 (수) 6792 6222 107 2 458 3 165 0/0 (n/a) 2
2026-06-04 (목) 6792 6222 9 55 435 71 463 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-06-05 (금) 6796 6224 1 3 477 91 182 0/0 (n/a) 2
2026-06-06 (토) 6820 6151 13 0 470 186 664 0/0 (n/a) 99
2026-06-07 (일) 6834 5907 0 0 741 186 935 0/0 (n/a) 258
2026-06-08 (월) 6839 5903 8 6 728 194 376 0/0 (n/a) 9
2026-06-09 (화) 6841 5807 0 0 759 275 577 0/0 (n/a) 99
2026-06-10 (수) 6851 5619 0 0 841 391 1055 0/0 (n/a) 200
2026-06-11 (목) 6857 5496 13 0 866 482 815 0/0 (n/a) 129
2026-06-12 (금) 6876 5512 3 12 855 494 348 0/0 (n/a) 4
2026-06-13 (토) 6888 5474 6 1 897 510 427 0/0 (n/a) 50
2026-06-14 (일) 6898 5434 0 0 913 551 486 0/0 (n/a) 50
2026-06-15 (월) 6922 5408 0 0 932 582 390 0/0 (n/a) 50
2026-06-16 (화) 6940 5371 5 0 956 608 415 0/0 (n/a) 55
2026-06-17 (수) 6960 5341 15 0 969 635 320 0/0 (n/a) 50
2026-06-18 (목) 6979 5258 4 0 1025 692 507 0/0 (n/a) 102
2026-06-19 (금) 6984 5187 44 0 1019 734 387 0/0 (n/a) 76
2026-06-20 (토) 6984 5187 10 17 1025 745 210 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-06-21 (일) 7020 5023 29 0 1129 839 783 0/0 (n/a) 200
2026-06-22 (월) 7048 4951 24 0 1171 902 668 0/0 (n/a) 100
2026-06-23 (화) 7055 4858 28 0 1209 960 583 0/0 (n/a) 100
2026-06-24 (수) 7075 4777 18 0 1240 1040 610 0/0 (n/a) 101
2026-06-25 (목) 7080 4683 65 2 1219 1111 520 0/0 (n/a) 100
2026-06-26 (금) 7083 4683 44 2 1243 1111 88 0/0 (n/a) 3
2026-06-27 (토) 7105 4605 25 0 1262 1213 904 2/2 (100.0%) 100
2026-06-28 (일) 7133 4522 8 0 1328 1275 663 1/1 (100.0%) 111
2026-06-29 (월) 7153 4443 24 0 1366 1320 618 2/3 (66.7%) 100
2026-06-30 (화) 7155 4345 62 4 1379 1365 572 1/1 (100.0%) 101
2026-07-01 (수) 7167 4257 38 1 1463 1408 712 4/4 (100.0%) 100
2026-07-02 (목) 7167 4256 10 9 1482 1410 537 6/7 (85.7%) 1
2026-07-03 (금) 7170 4159 28 0 1528 1455 628 6/6 (100.0%) 100
2026-07-04 (토) 7194 4083 68 4 1552 1487 635 7/9 (77.8%) 100
2026-07-05 (일) 7236 4025 15 0 1661 1535 867 8/9 (88.9%) 100
2026-07-06 (월) 7247 3936 36 0 1699 1576 746 16/19 (84.2%) 100
2026-07-07 (화) 7261 3850 30 0 1767 1614 796 18/20 (90.0%) 100
2026-07-08 (수) 7266 3855 9 24 1756 1622 355 9/11 (81.8%) 0
2026-07-09 (목) 7267 3856 1 17 1764 1629 429 27/31 (87.1%) 0
2026-07-10 (금) 7267 3856 0 24 1755 1632 139 7/8 (87.5%) 0
2026-07-11 (토) 7291 3770 31 0 1809 1681 1357 84/97 (86.6%) 110
2026-07-12 (일) 7309 3688 16 0 1895 1710 887 43/51 (84.3%) 101
2026-07-13 (월) 7309 3588 71 14 1890 1746 742 45/52 (86.5%) 100
2026-07-14 (화) 7321 3597 24 26 1931 1743 484 31/35 (88.6%) 3
2026-07-15 (수) 7322 3598 1 23 1956 1744 571 34/37 (91.9%) 0
2026-07-16 (목) 7328 3602 1 9 1968 1748 438 35/40 (87.5%) 2
2026-07-17 (금) 7329 3503 73 3 1979 1771 1098 125/137 (91.2%) 100
2026-07-18 (토) 7373 3447 23 0 2084 1819 847 60/66 (90.9%) 100
2026-07-19 (일) 7378 3452 5 19 2077 1825 433 35/37 (94.6%) 0
2026-07-20 (월) 7393 3367 22 0 2137 1867 1007 90/96 (93.8%) 100
2026-07-21 (화) 7407 3270 36 0 2194 1907 895 53/59 (89.8%) 111
2026-07-22 (수) 7407 3269 14 18 2198 1908 331 19/22 (86.4%) 1
2026-07-23 (목) 7422 3284 1 5 2224 1908 293 19/21 (90.5%) 0
2026-07-24 (금) 7430 3292 0 27 2204 1907 469 33/40 (82.5%) 0
2026-07-25 (토) 7453 3166 21 0 2268 1998 2069 389/408 (95.3%) 149
2026-07-26 (일) 7514 3078 7 0 2302 2127 1194 53/57 (93.0%) 149
2026-07-27 (월) 7521 2985 45 3 2325 2163 814 41/42 (97.6%) 100
2026-07-28 (화) 7524 2888 52 7 2351 2226 1024 39/42 (92.9%) 100
2026-07-29 (수) 7530 2795 60 0 2420 2255 999 35/37 (94.6%) 100
2026-07-30 (목) 7536 2801 34 8 2440 2253 306 6/9 (66.7%) 0
2026-07-31 (금) 7539 2704 38 5 2462 2330 1447 57/62 (91.9%) 100
2026-08-01 (토) 7548 2713 12 1 2492 2330 189 2/2 (100.0%) 0
2026-08-02 (일) 7588 2584 3 0 2583 2418 1724 52/57 (91.2%) 170
2026-08-03 (월) 7589 2585 0 1 2585 2418 28 2/2 (100.0%) 0
2026-08-04 (화) 7595 2546 12 6 2599 2432 537 15/16 (93.8%) 45
2026-08-05 (수) 7597 2547 0 27 2596 2427 562 23/29 (79.3%) 1
2026-08-06 (목) 7610 2560 0 17 2611 2422 796 41/48 (85.4%) 0
2026-08-07 (금) 7614 2563 0 11 2617 2423 825 39/44 (88.6%) 1
2026-08-08 (토) 7616 2565 0 0 2627 2424 68 3/3 (100.0%) 0
2026-08-09 (일) 7628 2477 42 1 2633 2475 1548 63/67 (94.0%) 100
2026-08-10 (월) 7631 2455 19 19 2638 2500 559 22/24 (91.7%) 25
2026-08-11 (화) 7633 2387 35 26 2635 2550 674 25/29 (86.2%) 70
2026-08-12 (수) 7635 2389 0 4 2660 2582 895 31/34 (91.2%) 0
2026-08-13 (목) 7651 2405 1 4 2632 2609 686 31/34 (91.2%) 0
2026-08-14 (금) 7652 2406 0 13 2620 2613 95 6/6 (100.0%) 0
2026-08-15 (토) 7653 2407 0 18 2590 2638 1125 57/63 (90.5%) 0
2026-08-16 (일) 7655 2387 0 8 2601 2659 408 30/35 (85.7%) 22
2026-08-17 (월) 7670 2302 39 0 2616 2713 1338 80/96 (83.3%) 100
2026-08-18 (화) 7672 2204 68 4 2632 2764 867 59/65 (90.8%) 100
2026-08-19 (수) 7674 2179 40 1 2683 2771 204 0/1 (0.0%) 27
2026-08-20 (목) 7681 2185 15 9 2703 2769 91 0/2 (0.0%) 1
2026-08-21 (금) 7681 2185 4 6 2716 2770 223 14/16 (87.5%) 0
2026-08-22 (토) 7681 2185 0 3 2721 2772 93 3/3 (100.0%) 0
2026-08-23 (일) 7703 2207 0 5 2704 2787 596 43/47 (91.5%) 0
2026-08-24 (월) 7708 2212 0 2 2688 2806 382 31/33 (93.9%) 0
2026-08-25 (화) 7717 2221 0 0 2672 2824 358 48/51 (94.1%) 0
2026-08-26 (수) 7722 2226 0 75 2570 2851 561 94/97 (96.9%) 0
2026-08-27 (목) 7724 2228 0 15 2628 2853 115 8/9 (88.9%) 0
2026-08-28 (금) 7724 2228 0 2 2634 2860 166 37/37 (100.0%) 0
2026-08-29 (토) 7743 2247 0 11 2621 2864 109 24/26 (92.3%) 0
2026-08-30 (일) 7748 2252 0 66 2500 2930 920 145/156 (92.9%) 0
2026-08-31 (월) 7754 2258 0 8 2512 2976 722 98/107 (91.6%) 0
2026-09-01 (화) 7757 2259 0 18 2452 3028 711 132/140 (94.3%) 2
2026-09-02 (수) 7763 2263 0 15 2435 3050 256 54/60 (90.0%) 2
2026-09-03 (목) 7766 2266 0 4 2437 3059 138 32/35 (91.4%) 0
2026-09-04 (금) 7766 2266 0 11 2405 3084 158 30/32 (93.8%) 0
2026-09-05 (토) 7772 2272 0 0 2397 3103 151 27/27 (100.0%) 0
2026-09-06 (일) 7780 2280 0 21 2343 3136 882 126/129 (97.7%) 0
2026-09-07 (월) 7787 2187 62 3 2312 3223 1577 274/290 (94.5%) 100
2026-09-08 (화) 7791 2088 53 6 2390 3254 689 62/67 (92.5%) 103
2026-09-09 (수) 7794 1991 75 25 2421 3282 819 63/67 (94.0%) 100
2026-09-10 (목) 7798 1992 73 15 2436 3282 35 0/0 (n/a) 3
2026-09-11 (금) 7804 1998 35 2 2488 3281 126 0/1 (0.0%) 0
2026-09-12 (토) 7821 2015 1 12 2498 3295 755 60/63 (95.2%) 0
2026-09-13 (일) 7830 2024 0 7 2504 3295 118 14/14 (100.0%) 0
2026-09-14 (월) 7839 2033 0 7 2499 3300 117 17/17 (100.0%) 0
2026-09-15 (화) 7847 2041 0 15 2474 3317 654 83/87 (95.4%) 0
2026-09-16 (수) 7852 2046 0 12 2473 3321 133 19/20 (95.0%) 0
2026-09-17 (목) 7856 2050 0 19 2453 3334 417 54/59 (91.5%) 0
2026-09-18 (금) 7856 2050 0 11 2460 3335 52 8/9 (88.9%) 0
2026-09-19 (토) 7856 2050 2 159 2256 3389 1024 187/199 (94.0%) 0
2026-09-20 (일) 7872 1866 76 15 2395 3520 2026 225/239 (94.1%) 200
2026-09-21 (월) 7872 1666 122 9 2472 3603 1086 65/68 (95.6%) 200
2026-09-22 (화) 7873 1467 180 70 2477 3679 1102 67/68 (98.5%) 200
2026-09-23 (수) 7873 1467 79 74 2573 3680 767 35/39 (89.7%) 0
2026-09-24 (목) 7875 1322 115 54 2634 3750 1422 93/100 (93.0%) 147
2026-09-25 (금) 7882 1329 98 17 2688 3750 85 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-09-26 (토) 7883 1330 51 98 2647 3757 727 61/66 (92.4%) 0
2026-09-27 (일) 7894 1341 3 18 2755 3777 1380 107/116 (92.2%) 0
2026-09-28 (월) 7900 1304 22 15 2758 3801 912 79/83 (95.2%) 43
2026-09-29 (화) 7904 1108 97 6 2835 3858 1055 54/62 (87.1%) 200
2026-09-30 (수) 7906 1108 42 23 2875 3858 275 6/7 (85.7%) 2
2026-10-01 (목) 7913 1115 14 48 2878 3858 598 38/40 (95.0%) 0
2026-10-02 (금) 7914 1116 7 10 2923 3858 67 0/0 (n/a) 0
2026-10-03 (토) 7914 1116 0 66 2856 3876 1746 144/157 (91.7%) 0
2026-10-04 (일) 7925 927 139 4 2908 3947 1255 96/103 (93.2%) 200

* * *

Update: I finished getting all the new cards into rotation, though I'm adding more every day, and there are still basic words to learn. Cards #8122 and #8123 are 윗옷 and 아래옷, tops and bottoms (i.e., shirt and pants). Though to be fair I already had the hanja equivalents 상의 and 하의 as cards #2611 and #2612.

date total cards new learning relearning young mature studied today mature retention new studied
2026-10-05 (월) 7925 927 39 2 3011 3946 260 1/2 (50.0%) 0
2026-10-06 (화) 7928 929 2 19 2999 3979 964 65/69 (94.2%) 1
2026-10-07 (수) 7929 929 0 15 2984 4001 1148 90/98 (91.8%) 1
2026-10-08 (목) 7934 933 0 10 2983 4008 381 29/32 (90.6%) 1
2026-10-09 (금) 7937 761 135 8 2956 4077 1243 74/78 (94.9%) 175
2026-10-10 (토) 7937 761 49 7 3041 4079 376 11/13 (84.6%) 0
2026-10-11 (일) 7937 761 7 28 3051 4090 932 71/76 (93.4%) 0
2026-10-12 (월) 7937 761 2 62 3018 4094 907 82/96 (85.4%) 0
2026-10-13 (화) 7957 581 65 4 3136 4171 1471 95/101 (94.1%) 200
2026-10-14 (수) 7959 583 41 3 3161 4171 151 1/1 (100.0%) 0
2026-10-15 (목) 7960 583 17 17 3170 4173 338 20/21 (95.2%) 1
2026-10-16 (금) 7963 586 9 12 3182 4174 206 15/15 (100.0%) 0
2026-10-17 (토) 7966 588 0 5 3198 4175 186 14/16 (87.5%) 1
2026-10-18 (일) 7969 2 284 6 3333 4344 3718 253/286 (88.5%) 589
2026-10-19 (월) 7969 2 99 53 3455 4360 1568 56/64 (87.5%) 0
2026-10-20 (화) 7977 2 44 15 3529 4387 1430 98/106 (92.5%) 8
2026-10-21 (수) 8013 2 5 5 3592 4409 1247 32/38 (84.2%) 36
2026-10-22 (목) 8025 3 3 1 3606 4412 58 1/1 (100.0%) 11
2026-10-23 (금) 8034 2 0 3 3617 4412 80 1/1 (100.0%) 10
2026-10-24 (토) 8039 0 0 62 3573 4404 573 44/48 (91.7%) 7
2026-10-25 (일) 8044 0 0 57 3604 4383 1394 121/126 (96.0%) 5
2026-10-26 (월) 8066 0 0 14 3700 4352 1133 146/154 (94.8%) 22
2026-10-27 (화) 8106 3 1 46 3752 4304 1917 179/190 (94.2%) 37

I would like to spend a little more time acknowledging some of the traps we can fall into in language learning. It is easy to waste time with a false sense of productivity that is actually procrastination, where you learn "about" the language without actually learning the language. That is, diving into deep cultural trivia, word etymologies, archaic terms (but I'll blame the fairy tales for that one), picking apart hanja, and learning the technical linguistic names for different parts of speech, to name a few.

It is easy to spend too much time doing Anki. There are days where I finish all of my scheduled reviews, and I run a filtered deck to do more, instead of doing something else. Partly this is because Anki becomes a safe space or a comfort zone. Rather than going out and seeking new material, new videos, new articles, new challenges, I can just hit the "more" button and keep doing Anki. And partly it's because Anki provides those sweet, sweet statistics. It is fun to see the review count going up, the "estimated total knowledge" going up, the number of mature cards going up, and the number of new cards going down. It is fun to have an sqlite database that I can query and make charts. And this is only with the basic arrangement — I am not even referring to the severe gamification mods you can see across /r/Anki. Reading a catlab article doesn't give me a score at the end.

I came across the word 환갑 which means your sixtieth birthday. Why is there a special name for that? The 환(還) means "return" and 갑(甲) is standing in for 갑자(甲子), which is the first in the cycle of sixty 간지(干支), derived from ten 천간(天干) and twelve 지지(地支) and from there leads to associations with the sun, moon, seasons, color, direction, animals, elements, etc. When you turn sixty years old, the 간지 for that year is the same as the one when you were born.

On the Korean flag, you can see four sets of lines. What are those? They are four of the 팔괘 (eight trigrams), which come from Chinese philosophy. The selected four are ☰ (하늘, sky) ☵ (물, water) ☲ (불, fire) ☷ (땅, earth). And yes, I've made cards for all eight so I can recognize them on sight.

I came across the word 신문고, which is a system by which the public can send complaints to the government. Nowadays, that takes the form of a website, but the 고(鼓) here means "drum", because it was originally a drum outside the king's palace that the citizens could strike.

Back to the topic at hand... or have we never left? This is what it looks like to procrastinate by learning. This is learning about the language without learning the language. This information will not help my listening comprehension. I literally got the 팔괘 into my Anki before 윗옷. I made it very clear earlier that I already know I'm guilty of this, and that I'm willing to "waste" some time learning words I don't really need. But yeah, my reading vocabulary is high enough now, and it's time for me to focus on listening comprehension so I can actually talk to people.

Change of pace (§)

I have spent quite a lot of time describing the ways in which I have failed. Failed to study, failed to speak, failed to be brave, etc. Let's have a slight change of tone here by saying something I am good at. I have always enjoyed listening to international accents and doing voices and, in my own opinion, I think my pronunciation is okay, though of course I will not say perfect or great. All of the Korean people I've met tell me that my pronunciation is good, always unprompted, but still I am careful to accept it. When I am doing a cold read on a new piece of text, I still have to go slow, and my rhythm is poor. I am not able to sight read yet because there is still so much vocabulary that I don't know. Even in English, you know it's hard to sight read quickly through a text that contains too much unknown vocubulary, such as something very dense with domain-specific jargon, so that's kind of how this feels all the time.

Agh, wait, this was the positive part. Anyway, when I am reading something that I'm familiar, I think I sound not terrible. Here:

요즘에 한국어를 열심히 공부하고 있습니다. 매일 Anki로 어휘를 공부하고, 운전할 때 팥케스트를 들어가요. 매주 목요일 일을 끝나서 얼바인에서 한영 언어 교환 모임에 가요. 그리고 격주, 이 주에 한 번씩, 수요일 OC 소스 몰에서 다른 모임도이 있어요. 집에서 혼자 있을 때나, 팥케스트를 들 때는, 제가 잘한다고, 많이 이해할 수 있다고 생각해요. 근데 현실의 상대방이랑 직접 얘기하면 참 어렵잖아요! 제 생각에는, 제 발음이 괜찮는데, 억양이나 진짜 문장을 만들기가 힘들다. 언어 교환 친구들이 다 착하고 응원해 주고 힘이 되어주세요.

와, 한국어에 관한 기사에 한국어 문단이 있네! 문법이 맞는지 틀린지, 표현이 자연스러운지 잘 모르겠는데, 재밌군요.

Listening to this, I think I need to fix my "서", but I'll leave it for now.

Anki (§)

I will describe to you my note and card templates, some practices I've been doing since the beginning that I'm glad for, some practices I wish I had done since the beginning, and some practices that I was doing at the beginning but have stopped.

I do 99.9% of my Anki on my phone with AnkiDroid, including the adding and editing of cards. Even when I am at home, I would mostly rather use my phone for Anki than my computer, which is funny since for almost everything else in my life it would be the opposite. The posture of sitting at the keyboard is not a pleasant way to study, for me. I have long since disassembled the ankibutton, but I've just recently bought a bluetooth controller and am enjoying it very much.

My Anki notes contain these fields:

Anki field remark
Korean Most of my notes are just a single word, but this is also sometimes a phrase or grammar pattern.
English Sometimes a single word, usually several possible synonyms or nuance.
Hanja If applicable.
KDef Korean definition from the dictionary.
Sentence Sometimes I'll copy one of the example sentences from the dictionary, or the original sentence where I heard the word. Oftentimes I'll leave this blank as I actually don't think it's critically important.
Pronunciation This is usually blank, but sometimes a reminder helps. For example, 솜이불 is pronounced [솜:니불]; 들일 is pronounced [들:릴]; 막일 is pronounced [망닐].
Hint To disambiguate homonyms, I need to give myself a hint. Most of the time, this is just the first letter of the English word.
다리 (l...) = leg
다리 (b...) = bridge
바르다 (to a...) = to apply; spread; put on; fill in
바르다 (to b...) = to be straight; upright; correct; righteous

I have been adding the hanja to my notes since the very beginning and I am glad that I have. I absolutely recommend you do the same. This makes it so much easier to search your collection for other words with the same hanja and therefore build a deeper understanding and connection to the vocabulary. Hey, 전차 has the same 전 from 전쟁. Literally, a war car!

I did not store the Korean dictionary definition in my notes until recently, and I wish that I had. I have not yet made the so-called monolingual transition of looking up words exclusively in the Korean dictionary and understanding their definitions that way. I hope that by capturing the KDef now, I can prepare to eventually do cards that are Korean→KDef, and anyways for the time being to engage with the Korean definitions moreso than I have in the past.

If/when I do switch to monolingual K→KDef cards, I'll have to be judicious with which of these notes become cards. Even if I've added the KDef for a word like "apple" as a way of helping me get familiar with how a dictionary defines an object or expresses an idea, I don't actually need that definition to help me understand what an apple is. There are going to be lots and lots of words for which the K→E cards are perfectly sufficient.

* * *

Almost all of my cards are just a single Korean word on the front and the English translations on the back. Sometimes I'll have a single verb as its own one-word card, and also as part of a set phrase card, because set phrases basically need to be memorized as independent vocabulary. For example, 간지럽다 = to be itchy, and 입이 간지렵다 = to be dying to say something (mouth is itching).

I know that some people encourage using mostly sentence cards. Once I get to the point that I am no longer encountering very many new single words, I may shift into a higher gear and start adding more and longer phrases as cards. I think this framing of "gears" is reasonable, since at the beginning you need to memorize the alphabet, then you need to practice reading syllables, then you practice words, then you practice phrases and idioms.

At my current skill level, I find that sentence cards or even phrase cards make it too easy to memorize the shape of the card and remember the answer before even reading the main key word in the sentence. For example, I can recognize "가슴이 덜컥 내려앉다" simply because I know it is the only card I have that starts with 가슴이, even if I completely ignore the rest of it. However, once there are several hundred sentence/phrase cards in the system, they will probably stand out less and less in this manner.

I added the Sentence field recently, at the same time that I added KDef. Although I fill in the KDef for all new words that I add now, I don't always add a sentence. For a lot of words, I think a sentence does not help me internalize the meaning moreso than the definition alone. The problem with vocabulary is that there's so much of it, but not usually that it's actually hard to understand. I do add a sentence if the word seems non-obvious to put into usage, or if it helps demonstrate an interaction between this word and another verb, or if it just seems interesting. If there's a particular usage or set phrase that I want to learn, I would just add it as its own card in the main field, rather than as the Sentence field of this word card.

I do not use audio or images on my cards.

From time to time I like to enable the whiteboard mode on Anki so that I can practice writing words. I do think this has helped with my ability to handwrite, but it does not otherwise lead to higher retention of the words for me. It winds up just being a slower way to review, and I think handwriting practice is maybe better done as a separate activity if the goal is handwriting improvement.

* * *

From the very beginning in 2018 until my recent restart, I had always had my Anki set to generate both Korean→English cards and also English→Korean cards. In language learning, these are referred to as Recognition (can you recognize the Korean word when you are reading/listening) and Production (can you produce the Korean word when you are writing/speaking).

I had both cards generating from the same Note. This, I have realized, was a mistake. I have now deleted the production cards and I am only doing recognition at the moment.

Production cards themselves are not the problem. The problem is using a single note to generate both the recognition and production cards. The root of this problem is synonyms. When reading a single Korean word on the front, there are usually several English words on the back in order to capture the nuance, connotations, and possible usages of the Korean word. This means that when generating a production card from this note, I'd have multiple English words on the front asking me to remember a single Korean word. But this is pointless, because of course there could be several Korean synonyms to pick from.

Given these notes:

You can see that using these notes to generate English→Korean production cards, having multiple English words on the front and only only one Korean answer on the back, is futile. Which is what I was doing.

During the time that I was doing this, I would add an E→K hint (this was another field, which I have since deleted) to disambiguate which of the Korean words was the right answer. But this becomes increasingly convoluted when both Korean words start with the same letter (oftentimes because they derive from the same hanja), and then when the second letter is also the same, and then when they have the same length, etc.

If you want to add production cards to your study, you really need to make them as a whole separate note. Maybe it would be something like:

Besides the synonym problem, there is another serious problem with generating both recognition and production from a single note: It is absolutely, completely normal for your passive vocabulary to be much larger than your active vocabulary, even in your native language. That means you can understand more words when you read or listen than you personally use when you write or speak. The ratio of your passive:active vocabulary in your native language is probably between 3:1 and 5:1 based on some quick internet searches. By generating both cards out of a single note, this creates a 1:1 study workload for recognition and production, which is fundamentally out of line with the reality of vocabulary. Plus, those production cards get failed more often because production is harder and because the cards themselves were flawed to begin with. Make separate notes.

At the moment, I am not making separate production notes, though. I want to finish working through all of my existing cards, get more listening and reading input, and see what comes out.

* * *

For most of this time, I tried to organize my newly added cards into subdecks. So my primary Anki deck is called "ㅎ", and within that I added ㅎ1, ㅎ2, ㅎ3. When you click on the main ㅎ to study, Anki will draw cards from all subdecks for review. And when you finish reviews and move into new cards, it would draw from ㅎ1 before ㅎ2, etc. So, when I was adding new words, I would use ㅎ1 for high priority words that I want to enter rotation soon, ㅎ3 for low priority words that I will not need for a long time, and ㅎ2 as the standard option. For whatever reasons, my experience with this was never quite perfect. When I would accidentally place cards in the wrong deck I would have to go fish them out again, and sometimes my card browser would browse ㅎ2 when I wanted it to search all ㅎ and I would not be seeing the results I expected. I don't know, I won't criticize it too much but it just never felt like an extension of me.

In my current phase of cramming vocabulary, I have dropped the subdecks and merged everything into ㅎ. I'm going to have all these cards in rotation within a few months, so there's no more splitting hairs about priority.

If I add a word and I want that card to be in rotation right away, I'll use the "grade now" button in AnkiDroid's card browser to mark it Again. If I add words that I know I don't need — such as, say, the majority of the periodic table of elements — I'll suspend them so that I can keep them around as a dictionary but not waste time memorizing them. So that is now the method of coarsely setting priority levels.

* * *

I just created a new page on my website which holds iframes to the different dictionaries (K→E, K→K, Hanja) as well as an image search and translator. This is useful because sometimes I want to try reading the K→K dictionary first, but fall back to the K→E dictionary if I need some help, and sometimes a word is in one dictionary but not the other, and of course it helps to have an image search to provide visual aid. So this all-in-one page saves me from having to open multiple tabs or go back and forth between links.

https://voussoir.net/koreaniframe

It would be neat if, instead of just iframing these pages, I would fully proxy the search and manipulate / minify the HTML to provide a more perfect interface. But I do not want to have to keep up with anything they might change along the way.

On my card template, the word itself is a clickable link to my iframe page. Up in the corners, I have links to Naver images (because their site wouldn't work with the iframes) and the word's hanja. At the bottom I have the KDef and sentence.

Here is my card template:

Front:

<div class="frontface" lang="ko">
<div><a href="https://voussoir.net/koreaniframe?q={{Korean}}">{{Korean}}</a>{{#Hint}} <span class="hint">({{Hint}})</span>{{/Hint}}</div>
</div>

Back:

{{FrontSide}}

<hr>

<div class="backface">
<div lang="en">{{English}}</div>
{{#Pronunciation}}<div lang="ko">[{{Pronunciation}}]</div>{{/Pronunciation}}

<div id="upperleft">
<div lang="ko" id="hanja" data-hanja="{{Hanja}}"><a href="https://hanja.dict.naver.com/search/?mflag=1&query={{Hanja}}">{{Hanja}}</a></div>
</div>

<div id="upperright">
<a id="imglink" href="https://m.search.
naver.com/search.naver?where=m_image&query={{Korean}}">img</a>
</div>

<div id="bottomstuff" lang="ko">
{{#Tags}}<div id="ankitags">{{Tags}}</div>{{/Tags}}
{{#KDef}}<div>{{KDef}}</div>{{/KDef}}
{{#Sentence}}<div>"{{Sentence}}"<div>{{/Sentence}}
</div>

</div>

Styling:

.card { xoutline: 1px solid white; }
.card > #qa { xoutline: 1px solid red; }
.card > #qa > .frontface { xoutline: 1px solid blue; }
.card > #qa > .backface { xoutline: 1px solid purple; }
.card > #qa > * > * { xoutline: 1px solid green; }

* { font-family: "Noto Sans KR Regular", "Noto Sans", "Noto", "Arial", "sans serif"; }

a
{
    position: relative;
    color: inherit;
    text-decoration: none;
}

.card
{
    font-size: 20px;
    position: absolute;
    bottom: 0; right: 0; left: 0; top: 0;
    display: grid;
    align-items: center;
    text-align: center;
    user-select: none;
    margin: 1px;
}

.frontface,
.backface
{
    max-width: 95%;
    margin: auto;
    text-wrap: pretty;
}

.frontface
{
    font-size: 1.5em;
}


#upperleft
{
    position: absolute;
    top: 4px;
    left: 4px;
    display: flex;
    flex-direction: column;
    justify-content: flex-start;
    align-items:center;
}

#hanja
{
    font-size: 1em;
    color: #ccc;
}
#hanja[data-hanja="-"]
{
    display: none;
}

#upperright
{
    position: absolute;
    top: 4px;
    right: 4px;
    display:flex;
    flex-direction: column;
    color: #ccc;
}

#bottomstuff
{
    position: absolute;
    bottom: 1em; left: 5%; right: 5%;
    display:flex;
    flex-direction: column;
    justify-content: end;
    color: #ccc;
}

#ankitags
{
    font-style: italic;
    font-size: 0.8em;
    width: 1px;
    margin:auto;
    text-align: center;
    overflow-wrap: normal;
    display: flex;
    justify-content: center;
    color: #ccc;
}

Language exchange groups (§)

I have been going to two different language exchange groups (한영 언어 교환 모임). Every other Wednesday I am at the OC Source mall in Buena Park, and every Thursday I am in Irvine.

Attending these meetups has been extremely helpful and I am grateful to the organizers. The main thing is these groups have helped me build the courage to actually speak. The first time I arrived it was completely nervewracking to say anything at all. I actually said oui at one point in my frazzled state. Everyone there tells me I'm doing pretty good.

In June, I visited K-Town LA to see if I could find any interesting spots. I wandered the streets for five hours and didn't strike up any conversations with anyone, and I spent most of my time regretting that I had answered the shop attendant at Kim's Home Center in English rather than Korean. I left town feeling pretty lousy for a number of reasons besides that.

Earlier this week, I went out for a walk in my neighborhood, and suddenly I heard a familiar sound behind me. Another gentleman was walking in the same direction as I was, listening to something on his phone. I stopped until he was a little closer, then, 안녕하세요, and we talked for several minutes about me learning Korean, him learning English, and his daughter trying to learn Korean as well. This conversation was maybe only 20-30% Korean and the rest English, but that's really good compared to where I was a few months ago. The confidence to even try talking to a stranger is exclusively thanks to spending time at the meetups. He lives around the corner from me and we exchanged phone numbers.

I have also realized how fortunate I am to live next to multiple large bubbles of Korean demographic. I imagine that if I were learning Korean while living in a different state, I would have a hard time finding people to practice with. But I'm within an hour of K-Town LA, Buena Park, Pasadena, Irvine, and broadly speaking the LA and Orange counties have large Asian populations. This is something I didn't properly appreciate when I was thinking "I shouldn't go to any meetups because I'm not ready to speak yet".

I always come home with notecards and new words that I should add to my Anki when I have some time.

There have been some days at the meetups where the conversation is largely dominated by a particularly talkative person with a particularly low Korean level — sometimes I mean not even knowing the famously-easy-to-learn alphabet — who spends the entire time talking in English. I'm not referring to one specific person, this is an archetype that I've seen a few times. Usually, the rest of the group is very excited to teach this person the basic yes/no/please/thank you, and then I am sitting there not learning anything for the better part of hour. Those days are frustrating to me. I would be 100% more fine with this if they wanted to just sit and listen, which is what I do when two native speakers are having a conversation at my table. Why would I interrupt free in-person native listening practice to ask an ignorant question in English? Of course I'll stay silent. This harkens back to an ancient tradition from my culture called "lurk more".

There are other days where the tide shifts, and I am at a table outnumbered by 원어민 and I can't keep up with what they're saying. So, I don't mean to be insulting, but to describe my feelings because that's the whole point of this website; and to say that if you try a meetup and it doesn't seem to be quite what you were looking for, you probably should keep going for a while to see what happens on a different day.

Based on my positive experiences so far, and the fact that these groups are still relatively far from home for me, I have been trying to muster the inspiration and courage to start a group, too. I think the population is here and they simply need a catalyst. I'll invite my neighbor.

So this is how they get me (§)

During the past several years' boom of so-called AI and more-aptly-called LLMs and even-more-aptly-called text generators, I have completely avoided using them. Mainly because they are surrounded by so much bad marketing that I don't want to endorse, and because I like to go against the mainstream.

But... they're pretty good for asking language questions. So that's how they've got me after all.

I saw one of the guys at language exchange asking the computer to provide expressions using a word or grammar pattern, translate the answer between both languages, and rephrase a given sentence into a more natural / idiomatic form or other variations. So, I'm sold on it. I gave mine the instruction to never use romanizations (which makes the answer so much more pleasant to read, even if the information is just coming from Wikipedia), to provide the relevant hanja for advanced vocabulary, and to not do any of that "you're absolutely right!" type stuff.

At first, I was using Gemini. It seemed mostly good, but I caught it making factual errors more than a few times. So in general, it is important not to ask questions that are too high above your ability to comprehend the answer. On October 9 (coincidentally, 한글날), Google reduced the power of the free tier, and it's pretty much dumb as rocks now, so I bailed and have switched to Kagi. Kagi just frontends for various providers, the default currently being Deepseek.

Deepseek seems to be quite skilled with Korean, and honestly I am not finding factual errors in its answers, only the occasional formatting mistake. It does a significantly better job at providing the correct hanja than Gemini, which I attribute to the fact that Deepseek is Chinese. At first, it was struggling to do the formatting the way I wanted. By reading the thought log, I was able to figure out where it was getting stuck, and through some iteration I have come up with a saved instruction that gets it to generate pretty good vocabulary word lists and, overall, provide answers that I like. This might change by tomorrow, but as of right now, here are my saved instructions:

Please use a professional tone of voice. Prioritize informational delivery over flowery prose. Write as if you are publishing an encyclopedia, not a blog article. Do not add conversational filler. Do not use the "it's not X, it's Y" sentence pattern. If I make an incorrect claim or a misspelling, please correct me without hesitation at the beginning of your response. It is ok for you to say "I don't know" when you have insufficient information.

When I ask a question relating to the Korean language, you must never include romanized Korean words, or English transliteration of Korean words in your response. I can read and write 한글.

When you use advanced or technical 한자어 in your prose, please include the word's corresponding 한자, in 정체자, in parentheses immediately after the word's first occurrence. Format it like this: "육십갑자 (六十甲子)". Always provide this gloss for 사자성어. Omit this gloss for words that would be considered basic, everyday vocabulary.

Whenever I ask you for a list of Korean vocabulary, please use this template as a starting guide: the heading for the table should be written in both Korean and English. The table should have at least three columns, being 표제어, 한자, and English. The 표제어 column must always be filled and contain the primary Korean word being defined, written in 한글. The 표제어 cell should be a hyperlink, following exactly this form, replacing both occurrences of XXX with the entry word, keeping the angle brackets, and applying no URL-encoding:

[XXX](<https://voussoir.net/koreaniframe?q=XXX>)

If the word is 순우리말, or is wholly 외래어, or is of unclear etymological origin, place an em-dash (—) in the 한자 column. If the word is 한자어, then the 한자 column must contain the corresponding 한자. If the word is 혼종어, the 한자 column should contain mixed script with both 한글 and 한자. For example, if the 표제어 is 옷장, then the 한자 column would contain 옷欌. Do not provide the origin for 외래어. Depending on the context of the question and the vocabulary being provided, you may add more columns beside these standard three. Sometimes, Korean has both a 순우리말 word and a 한자어 word for the same concept, such as 이빨 and 치아 both meaning "tooth", and these should be written as two separate rows in the table. Please break up separate tables by category. Do not repeat back these formatting instructions to me.

That produces answers like this and this and this. Those three chats together cost a total of $0.071, meaning seven cents. On the International Scale of Frivolous Spending, that's worth about half a sip of your sugary coffee.

I am as disgusted as anyone by the people who use this technology to create and disseminate more junk into the world. To no extent am I interested in letting it think or speak for me. But for gathering information and presenting it in the format of my choice, it really is too good to ignore.

Give it a try, I guess.

People often wonder how many words an average adult knows in their native language. They also wonder, more anxiously, what is a reasonable minimum number of words to be conversationally fluent in a new language. These are interesting trivia in their own right, of course, but the true combinatorial explosion of fluent language is in phrases, expressions, and idiomatic speech. It is not enough to use grammatically correct verb conjugations to sound normal. At language exchange, all of the English learners I've met are out of the basic vocabulary/grammar phase; they're learning expressions. 표현.

First, we can start by looking at basic word pairs. Even if you know the dictionary definition of each word individually, pairing words together immediately exponentiates their possible meaning as a phrase. With such an infinity of examples available, it is hard to pick a representative few to write about here. But take for example the phrase "put down", which can mean literally placing an object somewhere, or insulting/mocking someone, or euthanizing an animal, or writing into a form/document, or making a down payment on a purchase, or making a bet at the poker table, or... Even though each of these figurative meanings is pretty easy to trace back to the literal meaning, they still take on a value of their own. I know for sure that my flashcards for verbs do not capture this much nuance.

Then you have well-known expressions like "all bark and no bite", the meaning of which seems not too hard to intuit, but it's a set phrase you wouldn't just make up one day. You must hear it from someone else first. How about "all hat and no cattle", which is similar in meaning but evokes the cultural context of cowboys and surely must be regional in usage. I have not reached the level of learning many Korean 표현 quite yet, and certainly not with that level of integrated social context. Maybe the best 표현 I can give you so far is "빈 수레가 요란하다".

And finally, if you just take some time to pay attention to the next conversation you have in your native language, you'll notice that real spoken conversation is extremely sloppy and complicated compared to the neat grammar patterns we read about in our lessons. I have started listening more carefully to English and it's like I can't believe I even know how this works.

Matt did a video on set phrases that I think back to pretty often. The point is, you really must not attempt to translate your thoughts from one language to another, you just have to learn how they say it. And the only way to do that is to keep listening.

It is overwhelming to think of how much cumulative experience with phrases, idioms, and movie/song/cultural references there is in one's life. There is too much that you just won't find in a dictionary, and I don't just mean that euphemistically. You have a limited number of hours in the day, and every hour you spend ingesting one form of input is an hour that you are not ingesting another. I should think it impossible to fully "catch up" in a second language, and the goalposts when learning a language must be set with this understood. For what it's worth, this is not even a language phenomenon at all, really, because it's the same for your career and hobbies and community subcultures — you can only be in one place at a time.

But, there are pages full of idioms if you want to go ahead and learn some out of context:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:English-language_idioms

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Category:Korean_idioms

* * *

I find that people are too fascinated with little differences between languages that aren't actually different. Almost more than anything else, attempting to learn a second language will show you that people are pretty much the same everywhere. Everyone talks about the same stuff — it's just different words. I suppose I'm not allowed to make such universal claims when I barely know one and a quarter languages, but.

Take for example the concept of honorifics. Most monolingual English speakers, or at least Americans, probably don't know this word, but as soon as you step into Japanese, Korean, etc., everybody's talking about honorifics, not to mention speech levels in general. How foreign! How Asian! How tradition! But if you've ever seen a movie with a stereotypical English butler character, then you know very well that English has honorifics, and you know exactly what they sound like, and you can reproduce them on command. Even if you didn't know the word for it. Everyone around the world has ways to talk respectfully; in English we just do it with diction and register rather than grammar and morphology.

When people talk about the differences between two languages, I often think of this XKCD comic where he describes "sleep" as "go comatose for a few hours, hallucinate vividly, and then maybe suffer amnesia about the whole experience". You can make anything sound weird by putting more words to it. So I think what happens is people seek explanations for how their target language works, and they put a whole lot of words into these explanations, and it psyches them out into thinking that the target language is so crazy different from their native language, only because they've never put so many words into explaining their native language.

People often say that Korean and English are "backward" because English uses SVO and Korean uses SOV word order. In Korean, it's "I pizza eat". 나는 피자를 먹는다. I feel that for basic sentences, the difference is quite trivial and really does not come across as weird at all, after a moment. It's kind of like when you watch a black and white movie, and it barely takes a minute to get used to it despite, superficially, the huge difference between black and white film and our own color vision.

And really, English word order is quite flexible within some rules. It is not terribly uncommmon for a subject to come at the end of a sentence, says I. Nor the verb, he added. Noticeably strange, Yoda-speak is, but incomprehensible it is not. Creative use of word order is more often left to poetry, or reads as archaic, but I don't think people consider it a stumbling block to comprehension. Korean, likewise, doesn't actually mind too much if you happen to put your subject, object, or time and place at the end, or omit an implied verb.

효진: 되게 좋아하거든요, 저도. 김치찌개에 면 넣어서 먹는 거를.

효진: 보통 대학생들은, 특히 시험 기간이 되면, 도서관에서 공부하잖아요, 학교 도서관에서.

This kind of thing happens more in speech than in writing, because if you forgot to say a word, or want to add more clarity, you have to just say it at the end, whereas in writing you'd go back and edit it.

So, Korean and English are not backward just due to SVO/SOV. The larger and more daunting task is the ordering of entire phrases. It is not just a grammatical problem — thinking about this has made me even more aware and self-conscious of sentence- and conversation-level ordering of information. Depending on how you deliver an opinion, story, or question, you can prime the listener's understanding of your context, intentions, and emotional state, and convey the relative importance of each part. And crucially, you can hit them with a joke. We often start sentences with a disclaimer like "I know this is going to sound weird, but..." because we anticipate how people will react to what we're going to say and we try to deliver it appropriately.

Especially in speech, being strictly linear, the order of your words slowly reveals your thought to the listener, and you have to appreciate your level of control over that reveal, like a magician. When I am trying to construct a Korean sentence, I find myself thinking "wait, I don't want to say that word yet, I want to save that for later", but I can't because it's supposed to come first.

I have been particularly aware of the differences in "importance" ordering when I am reading definitions in the dictionary. I'm not sure if I'll find the best examples now, but here's a few:

계기
길이, 면적, 무게, 양 등이나 온도, 시간, 강도 등을 재는 기구나 장치.
literally: "length, area, weight, quantity etc. or temperature, time, force etc. measuring tool or device"

Compare with English:

meter
an instrument for measuring, especially one that automatically measures and records the quantity of something, as of gas, water, miles, or time, when it is activated.

In English, you get "an instrument" within two words, and to clarify it's not for music, you get "measuring" within four. Whereas in Korean you don't even find out that it's a noun until the very end (context clues notwithstanding).

Another:

단열재
열이 밖으로 빠져나가거나 안으로 들어오는 것을 막는 데 쓰이는 건축용 재료.
literally: "(heat) (going out or coming in) (used to block) (construction material)"

thermal insulation
material of relatively low heat conductivity used to shield a volume against loss or entrance of heat by radiation, convection, or conduction

To me, the Korean ordering seems backward, not because of the VO/OV difference between "blocks heat" and "heat blocks", but because it seems more prudent for me to start a definition of an object with what it basically is, then clarify with further detail. If someone asks me what "thermal insulation" is, I'd lead with the fact that it's a material, then describe properties of that material. It seems more ... respectful? ... to the listener's attention to order it that way? The Korean dictionary describes all the properties first, and then the word 재료/material is literally last. This is the difference that must be learned.

Yes, I've been watching some English linguistics videos recently, too.

* * *

People also like to notice how Korean often omits subjects or objects that can be inferred. For example:

밥 먹었어요?
Eaten food?

예, 먹었어요.
Yes, eaten.

Yes, it sounds weird when it's translated so literally that way. But this is just another case of "hallucinating vividly", where you can make anything sound weird if you do it on purpose. In English, we'd say "have you eaten?" and "yes, I have". Have what? The actual verb for the past tense auxilliary "have" is omitted in the English response, because it's obvious. So the subject is often omitted in Korean when it's obvious, too, even though Korean may choose to preserve the original verb where English drops it.

Here's an example of how omitted subject can be used humorously:

경은: 효진 씨, 친구들 자주 만나요?
Hyojin, do you get together with your friends often?

효진: 자주 못 만나요, 바빠서.
Not too often, busy.

경은: 아, 바빠서. 효진 씨가 바빠서요? 아니면 친구들이 바빠서요?
Ah, busy. You're busy? Or your friends are busy?

효진: 친구들이 바빠서...
My friends are busy...

* * *

You've noticed by now the way I talk about "other people being too fascinated by ..." as if they should be embarrassed for being fascinated by something. What a jerk! Do I actually believe that? On one hand, yes. There is a lot of thing, Japan that goes on out there, and a lot of "In Japan, they have an ancient tradition..." about something mundane, and a lot of "hallucinating vividly" to make the foreign language sound more exotic than our native language. People get tattoos on their spines of hanzi/kanji meaning "love" or "strength" that they don't actually know how to read because hell if hanzi don't look way cooler than our alphabet.

I go to the international market, buy some Korean candy for three times the price I'd normally pay for candy, and then, yep, it's just candy. We seek to buy products that come from our country of interest even if they are not actually different or better simply because they carry the aura we want to carry. This behavior smells desperate, insecure, uncritical. When I go to events like the 626 Night Market or, yesterday, the LA Korean Festival, I am disappointed by how many of the stalls are just selling ordinary plastic, consumerist, intellectual-property-laden crap, and by the 화채 stalls advertising "AS SEEN ON TIKTOK". I will once again direct you to Ghost Dog for more on this.

(nota bene: The LAKF had a long corridor of stalls selling food products that came across as very authentic to me, with lots of handwritten prices and many clearly handmade goods. Those were the vendors you'd have to speak Korean to if you needed to ask anything.)

On the other hand, no, I don't like this negativity either. I have made the mistake once or twice of stopping by /r/languagelearningjerk, a wonderfully egalitarian community in which everyone is treated as a complete loser. Here, anything you think is interesting is actually not interesting; anything you think is fun is actually not fun; and your motivations for doing absolutely anything are absolutely wrong. A visit here is a complete and total drenching in self-doubt.

Clearly I have standards, maybe high standards, for tasteful appreciation of other culture. But it is not fun to be constantly questioning myself as to whether I think such-and-such is beautiful because I actually think it's beautiful, or because I'm a basic normie falling for the exoticism trap. There is not a single person in my life asking me to justify any of this, except myself.

People say that there are some 7,000+ languages spoken in the world, which, for reasons that are hard to articulate, genuinely stresses me out when I try to think about it. One of my reasons for choosing Korean is because I want to be different from all the people learning Japanese. So I basically took one step down the trendy-language ladder, a ladder with 7,000+ rungs, and I pretend that's even a little bit out of the mainstream?

When I once told someone at language exchange that I want to be different, she taught me the word 홍대병, basically "hipster disease", which is perfect for me.

Artifacting (§)

I don't want to be a complete -boo per se, but I wanted to get a few decorations at home of an Asian aesthetic. Yes. Sorry for the whiplash.

I became interested in the 훈민정음 (wikisource), the document that introduced the new 한글 alphabet to the public. I ordered a large 24x32 canvas print of the first page.

I produced the vector file for this by taking the best photograph/scan I could find online into Inkscape and, over the course of several evenings, tracing each character by hand.

Here you go:

I'm too busy getting this tattooed on my spine, so I don't have time to memorize the Chinese reading of this text, but working on this project has helped me get a little more familiar with a few more hanja — I won't miss 音 in a lineup, at least. I can point to some of the landmarks and paraphrase it, if need be.

I also bought one pack of Japanese 花札 cards and two packs of Korean 화투 cards with the intention of turning these into framed pieces of wall art, like as tall 4x12 grids. But I haven't gotten around to it yet.

And a cute 뚝배기 from Kim's Home Center.

Conclusion (§)

omg look at how much time I spent writing this when I could have been studying instead!

I have been very busy for the past few months and felt overwhelmed most of the time. I have been slowly adding to this article up to and including October 5. So I don't feel I have written this out as well as I'd like, and I wonder if my pessimism got a little bit way too strong for a moment there.

Just today, I passed a group of 할머니 at the farmers market, so I said 안녕하세요 and 좋은 하루 돼세요. Merely an hour later, I was introduced by a mutual friend to another neighbor of Korean background, who coincidentally happened to be walking by, who said she doesn't have enough people to practice with. I really think I need to be the one to start this 모임, so I am working on a poster and looking for spots to post it.


View this document's history

Contact me: writing@voussoir.net

If you would like to subscribe for more, add this to your RSS reader: https://voussoir.net/writing/writing.atom